The Peculiar September Phenomenon: Why Baseball Sees a Surge of Bizarre Events

Published in Humor and Quirks on Wednesday, August 20th 2025 at 8:36 GMT by Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Every year, something strange happens in Major League Baseball during the month of September. It’s not a sudden shift in team performance or a predictable statistical trend; it's a surge of unusual, often inexplicable events that leave fans scratching their heads and commentators scrambling for explanations. From bizarre collisions to improbable plays and unexpected rule interpretations, September baseball consistently delivers moments that defy logic and challenge our understanding of the game. This year is proving no different, prompting renewed investigation into what’s behind this peculiar phenomenon.

The Yahoo Sports article highlights several recent examples illustrating this “September weirdness.” One particularly memorable incident involved a collision between Guardians pitcher Tanner Bibee and Blue Jays batter Kevin Kiermaier, resulting in a chaotic scramble for the ball and a series of comical reactions from players and fans alike. Then there's the ongoing saga surrounding umpire Phil Cuzzi’s interpretation of the balk rule, leading to confusion and frustration across multiple games. These aren't isolated incidents; they are part of a recurring pattern that seems uniquely tied to the month of September.

So, what exactly is going on? While no definitive answer exists, several theories attempt to explain this strange trend. The most common explanation revolves around the increased pressure and stakes associated with late-season baseball. As teams fight for playoff spots, players are more tense, managers are making bolder decisions, and umpires are under intense scrutiny. This heightened atmosphere can lead to mistakes, unusual reactions, and a greater likelihood of unexpected events unfolding on the field.

The article also points to the potential impact of fatigue. The grueling 162-game season takes its toll on players both physically and mentally. As September rolls around, even the most seasoned veterans are feeling the effects of months of constant travel and intense competition. This fatigue can lead to lapses in judgment, decreased reaction times, and an increased susceptibility to injury – all factors that contribute to bizarre occurrences.

Another intriguing theory suggests a psychological element at play. The article references Dr. Richard Wolff, a sports psychologist who believes September baseball might be influenced by the “law of large numbers.” This principle states that as the number of trials (in this case, games) increases, the probability of rare and unusual events occurring also rises. Simply put, with more games being played in September, there’s statistically more opportunity for something strange to happen.

Furthermore, the article explores the possibility that changes in routine contribute to the phenomenon. Players often experience shifts in their daily schedules during September as teams adjust travel plans and game times to maximize playoff chances. These disruptions can impact performance and increase the likelihood of unexpected errors or unusual plays. The increased media attention and scrutiny also add pressure, potentially influencing player behavior and contributing to the overall sense of unpredictability.

The article delves into historical examples, noting that this "September weirdness" isn't a new development. Throughout baseball history, fans have consistently reported experiencing similar patterns of bizarre events during the final month of the season. This suggests that it’s not simply a product of recent changes in the game but rather an inherent characteristic of late-season baseball.

The discussion extends to umpire performance as well. While umpires are professionals trained to make quick and accurate calls, the pressure cooker environment of September can lead to increased scrutiny and potential for errors. The article highlights Phil Cuzzi’s balk interpretations as a prime example, demonstrating how even seemingly straightforward rules can be subject to varying interpretations under intense pressure.

Ultimately, the "September weirdness" remains an enigma. It's likely a combination of factors – heightened pressure, fatigue, psychological influences, changes in routine, and the sheer probability of rare events occurring – that contribute to this peculiar phenomenon. While we may never fully understand why baseball gets so strange in September, it’s undoubtedly one of the most entertaining and unpredictable aspects of the sport, providing fans with countless memorable moments and fueling endless speculation about what might happen next. It's a reminder that even in a game governed by rules and statistics, there's always room for the unexpected – especially when September rolls around. The article concludes that embracing this inherent strangeness is part of what makes baseball so captivating, offering a unique blend of skill, strategy, and sheer unpredictability.

N※N

The Peculiar September Phenomenon: Why Baseball Sees a Surge of Bizarre Events